| 2/1 | Hamline University | No. 2 | Dillon Sterle | W 8-6 | Dan Cromwell / Sam Teitelbaum |
|---|
| 2/7 | Michigan Tech | No. 2 | Dillon Sterle | L 5-8 | Brandon Ellefson / Anders Sandholm |
|---|
| 2/14 | at University of St. Thomas | No. 2 | Dillon Sterle | L 4-8 | Phil Hanke / Kevin Walker |
|---|
| 2/21 | at Bethel University | No. 2 | Dillon Sterle | L 5-8 | Joel Cassens / Jordan LeFebvre |
|---|
| 2/22 | at Saint John's University | No. 2 | Dillon Sterle | L 4-8 | Kevin Goihl / Dutch Hansen |
|---|
| 3/9 | vs. Coe College | No. 2 | Dillon Sterle | L 0-8 | Ryan King / Scott Stegemann |
|---|
| 3/11 | vs. St. Ambrose University | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-1 | Mike Flynn / Andrew Sisto |
|---|
| 3/11 | vs. Ursinus College | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-3 | Jason Zerbe / Kevin Dean |
|---|
| 3/12 | vs. St. Francis (IL) | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-1 | Sean Markert / Eddie Semik |
|---|
| 3/13 | vs. Oxford College of Emory | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-1 | Ryan Sessions / Jonathan Shieh |
|---|
| 3/20 | Bethany Lutheran | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-0 | Ben Wiechmann / Peter Londgren |
|---|
| 3/21 | Concordia-Moorhead | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-2 | David Bloomquist / Bryn Homuth |
|---|
| 3/28 | at Northwestern College | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-0 | Ken Linehan / Garrett Lahr |
|---|
| 4/5 | at Bethany Lutheran | No. 1 | Cody Bottem | W 8-3 | Mike Lukasek / Paul Webber |
|---|
| 4/7 | at Minnesota, Morris | No. 2 | Brian Lindberg | W 8-2 | Tyson Mastin / Chris Haglin |
|---|
| 4/15 | Northwestern College | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-2 | Jay Werness / Ken Linehan |
|---|
| 4/17 | vs. Luther College | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | L 4-8 | Scott Martin / Max Piepkorn |
|---|
| 4/23 | at North Central University | No. 2 | Kevin Hilpert | W 8-1 | Ben CHRISTENSEN / Corey KALINOWKSKI |
|---|
| 4/25 | Minnesota, Morris | No. 3 | Cody Bottem | W 8-0 | Kevin Daly / Zach Ranallo |
|---|
| 5/1–2 | 2009 Men's UMAC Tournament | Semifinal | Cody Bottem | W 8-1 | Steven Wesbur / Caleb Power |
|---|
| 5/1–2 | 2009 Men's UMAC Tournament | Consolation | Cody Bottem | W 8-2 | Ryan Obry / Daniel Rick |
|---|
