| 2008 ITA Consolation vs. First Round | no result |
| Round of 64 | Max PiepkornLUT def. Kyle RiegelLOR | 8-0 |
| Round of 64 | L Kevin GoihlSJU def. Dillon SterleSt. Scholastica | 8-6 |
| Round of 64 | Brady PorterUWW def. Adam BernekingLUT | 8-0 |
| Round of 64 | Arnie AndreasenCC def. Brandon StensethUWLC | 8-2 |
| Round of 64 | Austin SveomCWIS def. Alex JonesGAC | 8-4 |
| Round of 64 | Thomas OrserLUT def. Alex MoryUWW | 8-4 |
| Round of 64 | L Dylan GummGRIN def. Brian LindbergSt. Scholastica | 8-1 |
| Round of 64 | Doug LandCOE def. Chris GustasWART | 8-1 |
| Round of 64 | Max PeckskampSJU def. Michael KreklauBU | 8-3 |
| Round of 64 | Juliano BeckerCWIS def. Travis FondowLAWR | 8-1 |
| Round of 64 | Matt EdinCC def. Mark SansaitUWW | 8-1 |
| Round of 64 | W Brendan AndersonSt. Scholastica def. Caleb RayLAWR | 8-5 |
| Round of 64 | David KlausLAWR def. Chris CraigCWIS | 8-1 |
| Round of 64 | W Jacob EngelstadSt. Scholastica def. Aaron MastersonWART | 8-0 |
| Round of 64 | Eric RitterGRIN def. Lars OlsonUWEC | 8-7 (9-7) |
| Round of 64 | Nate JungLUT def. Giovani BeckerCWIS | 8-7 (7-2) |
| Round of 64 | Doug MarmarUWLC def. Pat HopsonLOR | 8-0 |
| Round of 64 | Jake ReitzLUT def. Justin WeberCWIS | 8-1 |
| Round of 64 | Timmy MollerUWW def. Chris AjluniCOE | 8-2 |
| Round of 64 | Joe HolguinLOR def. James NyugenWART | 8-1 |
| 2008 ITA Consolation vs. Second Round | no result |
| Round of 32 | Max PiepkornLUT def. Walker WilsonWART | 8-1 |
| Round of 32 | Kevin GoihlSJU def. Jon NelsonBU | 8-1 |
| Round of 32 | Brady PorterUWW def. Prateek HaralalkaCOE | 8-0 |
| Round of 32 | Arnie AndreasenCC def. Austin SveomCWIS | 8-4 |
| Round of 32 | Thomas OrserLUT def. Brooks StapletonGAC | 8-5 |
| Round of 32 | Kyle HalwegUWW def. Dylan GummGRIN | 8-4 |
| Round of 32 | Tyler Van HeestLUT def. Doug LandCOE | 8-2 |
| Round of 32 | Max PeckskampSJU def. Juliano BeckerCWIS | 8-1 |
| Round of 32 | Matt EdinCC def. Austin MerrillLOR | 8-0 |
| Round of 32 | L Daniel PomerancGAC def. Brendan AndersonSt. Scholastica | 8-6 |
| Round of 32 | W Jacob EngelstadSt. Scholastica def. David KlausLAWR | 8-2 |
| Round of 32 | Eric RitterGRIN def. John KeaneLOR | 8-2 |
| Round of 32 | Doug MarmarUWLC def. Nate JungLUT | 8-4 |
| Round of 32 | Jake ReitzLUT def. Sam ScheevelBU | 8-0 |
| Round of 32 | Timmy MollerUWW def. Bryn HomuthCC | 8-1 |
| Round of 32 | Mark MateskiLUT def. Joe HolguinLOR | 8-1 |
| 2008 ITA Consolation vs. Third Round | no result |
| Round of 16 | Kevin GoihlSJU def. Max PiepkornLUT | 8-1 |
| Round of 16 | Brady PorterUWW def. Arnie AndreasenCC | 8-0 |
| Round of 16 | Thomas OrserLUT def. Kyle HalwegUWW | 8-1 |
| Round of 16 | Tyler Van HeestLUT def. Max PeckskampSJU | 8-7 (10-8) |
| Round of 16 | Daniel PomerancGAC def. Matt EdinCC | 8-7 (7-0) |
| Round of 16 | L Eric RitterGRIN def. Jacob EngelstadSt. Scholastica | 8-2 |
| Round of 16 | Jake ReitzLUT def. Doug MarmarUWLC | 8-3 |
| Round of 16 | Timmy MollerUWW def. Mark MateskiLUT | 8-4 |
| 2008 ITA Consolation vs. Quarterfinal | no result |
| Quarterfinal | Brady PorterUWW def. Kevin GoihlSJU | 8-4 |
| Quarterfinal | Thomas OrserLUT def. Tyler Van HeestLUT | 8-2 |
| Quarterfinal | Daniel PomerancGAC def. Eric RitterGRIN | 8-6 |
| Quarterfinal | Timmy MollerUWW def. Jake ReitzLUT | 8-0 |
| 2008 ITA Consolation vs. Semifinal | no result |
| Semifinal | Thomas OrserLUT def. Brady PorterUWW | 8-3 |
| Semifinal | Daniel PomerancGAC def. Timmy MollerUWW | 8-5 |
| 2008 ITA Consolation vs. Championship | no result |
| Consolation | Daniel PomerancGAC def. Thomas OrserLUT | by walkover |
